All-Star Puzzles
Home Contact Help Log Innot logged in
Last-Minute Tax Returns
Five couples file their 1040s first thing this morning.
April 17, 2006
By clue 1, the couple receiving the largest refund will be getting back twice as much money from the IRS as the couple with the 2nd-biggest refund. Since Keith and his wife will be receiving a refund of $1,500 (clue 8), the gap between the largest two refunds must be at least $750. In clues 4 and 7, then, given the $500 gap between their refunds and other refunds, neither Lon and his wife nor Mark and his will be getting the most back; so, in those two clues, either Mark and his wife get the 2nd- and Lon and his wife the 3rd-biggest income tax refund or vice versa. If Mark and his wife were getting the 2nd- and Lon and his wife the 3rd-largest refunds, by clue 4, Ellen and her husband would be getting the 4th-most money back and the Rodmans would be getting the 5th-most. By clue 7, with Mark and his wife getting the 2nd-biggest refund, Mrs. Truman couldn't be Ellen or both Mark and his wife and Lon and his would be getting the same refund (4, 7)--no, by the introduction. Mr. Truman would have to be Lon, or there would be more than five couples. Then Debra in clue 7 would have to be Mrs. Rodman in clue 4 or there would be more than five couples. However, the gap between Lon and his wife and Debra Rodman and her husband would be $1,500 in clue 4 and $500 in clue 7. Therefore, Lon and his wife are getting the 2nd- and Mark and his wife the 3rd-largest refunds. By clue 7, the 4th-most money back is to the Trumans and the 5th-most to Debra and her husband. Debra must be Mrs. Rodman in clue 4 or there would more than five couples. Since both Ellen (4) and Mark (7) are recipients of $1,000 more than Debra Rodman and her husband (4, 7), Ellen and Mark must be a couple since no two are receiving the same amount back from the IRS. By clue 2, Ian is Mr. Truman. If Keith and his wife's refund of $1,500 (8) were the largest, Lon and his wife would be getting back $750 (1)--impossible, since in clue 4 the Rodmans would then owe money. So, Keith is Mr. Rodman, with Jeff and his wife due the largest refund. Keith and Debra Rodman are getting $1,500 back (8), so the Trumans are getting $2,000 and Mark and Ellen $2,500 (7). Lon Truman and his wife are due $3,000 (4), and Jeff and his wife will receive a check for $6,000 (1). By clue 3, Lon is Mr. Paulman and Brenda Mrs. Truman. Jeff's wife is Christie and Lon's is Alice (5). By clue 6, Jeff and Christie are the Wymans, and Mark and Ellen are the Shermans. In sum, the five last-minute couples are due income tax refunds as follows:

  • Jeff & Christie Wyman, $6,000
  • Lon & Alice Paulman, $3,000
  • Mark & Ellen Sherman, $2,500
  • Ian & Brenda Truman, $2,000
  • Keith & Debra Rodman, $1,500

Copyright © 2002-2018 All-Star Puzzles. All rights reserved.
Contact | Help | Privacy Policy