| From the introduction, the Darby jugs are displayed in a 3x3 case (3 rows of
3 columns), one jug per space. By clue 4, on one shelf the "Robin Hood" jug
sits between the "Fox Hunter" and the jug bought in Blackpool. By clue 5, in
spaces atop each other, the "Grenadier" is displayed directly above the Darby
jug purchased in London, which is shown directly above the "King Henry VIII"
likeness. Since Colleen didn't buy the "King Henry VIII" jug in Blackpool (8),
the three jugs in clue 4 are on the middle or top shelf. By clue 1, the mug
acquired in Durham sits immediately above the "Gamekeeper" one. Since the jug
bought in Durham is neither the "Fox Hunter" nor the "Robin Hood" jug (10), the
Durham purchase isn't on the same shelf as the three in clue 4. If the three
in clue 4 were on the middle shelf, the jug bought in Durham would have to sit
above the "Gamekeeper" (1) from Blackpool--no (8). So, the three jugs in clue 4
are displayed on the top shelf. By clue 5, then, the "Grenadier" must be the jug
purchased in Blackpool; and the London buy and then the "King Henry VIII" jugs sit
directly under it. By clue 9, the jug Colleen got in Plymouth is shown between
the "Sherlock Holmes" and the one bought in Coventry. If these jugs were on the
middle shelf, the London purchase would be the "Sherlock Holmes" jug, a
conflict with clue 12. Therefore, on the bottom shelf, the jug Colleen acquired
in Plymouth is in the middle between the "King Henry VIII" from Coventry and the
"Sherlock Holmes." Since the jug purchased in Durham isn't on the top shelf (10),
by clue 1, it sits in the center of the middle row above the "Gamekeeper" likeness
from Plymouth. By clue 3, the "Old Tar" must be the jug purchased in Durham, with
the jug bought in Dover displayed under the "Fox Hunter." By clue 11, Colleen
bought the "Sherlock Holmes" in Bristol. She got the "Bobby" jug in London and the
"Barrister" in Dover (6). The "Robin Hood" jug is from York and the "Fox Hunter"
from Gloucester (7). By clue 2, the "Fox Hunter" from Gloucester isn't in the
upper left corner, so it must be in the upper right with the Blackpool "Grenadier"
in the top left. Colleen has the Darby jugs displayed in order facing the
case and going from left to right and top to bottom:
- The "Grenadier," Blackpool
- "Robin Hood," York
- The "Fox Hunter," Gloucester
- The "Bobby," London
- The "Old Tar," Durham
- The "Barrister," Dover
- "King Henry VIII," Coventry
- The "Gamekeeper," Plymouth
- "Sherlock Holmes," Bristol
|
|
|
